I’m delighted to share that my short essay ‘התינוק, המים, המזגן והממ”ד‘ (‘The Baby, the Water, the Air Conditioner and the Safe Room’) has been published in Alaxon, a Hebrew-language digital journal on science, philosophy, culture and art.
It starts with a young woman walking home on a dark street, one hand on a can of pepper spray in her pocket. It’s a useful bit of technology: it makes her a little safer, or at least feels that way. But it also raises a question: if tools like this didn’t exist, would we hear more demands for solutions at the level of society, such as safer streets, better enforcement, and education against violence?
My argument is that technology which works well for the individual can carry a quiet cost for everyone else. The better it works, the easier it becomes to avoid asking whether the system itself should change. I call the long-term result moral atrophy.
I look at two more examples, both of which I treat with care. One is Ritalin. It helps many children and adults to focus. But it can also let us avoid asking whether we are creating the right environment for children, in classrooms built on old ideas about learning and in a world designed to fragment attention.
Another technology is medical gender-affirming treatment. It can greatly improve the lives of people with gender dysphoria, but it can also let us avoid reconsidering a too-strictly two-box view of sex and gender.
I’m clear in the essay that the individual should not pay the price: people who need these technologies should have access to them, just as someone who can’t walk should have a wheelchair. The point is to see what we, as a society, are tempted to put off.
My suggestion is to give these technologies something like the warning leaflet that comes with medicine, through writing and public discussion, and to build ways of making sure we also invest in a ‘social check-up’, so that the fix for the individual doesn’t replace the work of changing society.
You can read the full essay (in Hebrew) here.
Image credit: Denny Müller on Unsplash (cropped)
