Last week, I presented at the ECPR General Conference in Hamburg, as part of the panel The Escalation Dynamics of Policy Conflicts.
The panel asked a question that often gets overlooked: how do policy conflicts heat up? The escalation of a conflict, the moment a disagreement turns volatile, is often neglected within the field of interpretative policy analysis. Our panel looked at it through an interpretive lens, focusing on clashing meanings, framing contests, emotions, and how events change the story.
My contribution added a dimension that tends to get left out: the visuals. In debates over new technologies, where much is uncertain, images can play a big role. They mix facts, emotion, opinion and rhetoric, and they travel fast.
I presented our analysis of images published online by actors in the shale gas debate in the Netherlands and South Africa. We show how, while some images simply pass on objective information, others are meant to stir emotions and convey normative messages. We also looked at what the images were being used for: packaging facts, providing evidence, or making a rhetorical point.
What came out of this is that the images reflect how a science and technology conflict is being handled, and how the technology itself is governed. Put together, they create a kind of visual snapshot of the debate at a given moment, and that snapshot tells us things we might not see from the text alone.
Thank you to the panel convenors, Imrat Verhoeven and Wouter van Dooren, and to everyone in the room for the thoughtful discussion.

