I recently presented at the International Conference in Ideology and Discourse Analysis 2019 at the University of Essex, as part of the panel “The Image in the Plural.” My paper, co-authored with Tamara Metze and Huub Dijstelbloem, was called “The Role of Visualisation in Controversies over Technological Developments.”
Photos, maps and diagrams are all around us in debates over new technologies, but we tend to treat them as decoration. We wanted to take them seriously. When people argue over a technology, they don’t just tell a story; they show one, and that shapes the controversy.
To explore this, drawing on the Dynamic Discourse Coalitions approach, we looked at images used in the debate over shale gas extraction (“fracking”) in three places, and we found that images repeat and reinforce a group’s story, connect groups that tell different stories, or sharpen the tension between them.
Images can even become so dominant that they start to act like actors in the controversy themselves, rather than just illustrating it. We think this has to do with what makes images special: they are compact, yet flexible in meaning, and that meaning can shift over time.
Our takeaway is that visuals offer another lens for understanding the values and concerns that shape how emerging technologies are governed.
Thank you to the panel organisers and everyone in the room for the questions and conversation.


