JEPP article

Now Published: What Images Do in the Shale Gas Debate

———

My article Visual discourse coalitions: visualisation and discourse formation in controversies over shale gas development, co-authored with Huub Dijstelbloem and Tamara Metze, is now out in the Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning.

Debates over energy technologies are rarely fought with words alone. For example, shale gas (“fracking”): alongside the arguments, there is a flow of images, from drilling rigs to flames at a kitchen tap. We wanted to know what those images actually do. Do they simply back up what people are saying, or do they shape the debate in their own right?

To find out, we looked at how people and organisations talked about and visualised shale gas online in three very different places: the Netherlands, New York State, and South Africa. We compared the story told in words with the story told in images, and asked what happens when the two line up, or don’t.

It turns out that images can pull groups together or push them apart. Sometimes a shared visual story strengthens a group’s shared message. Sometimes it creates a divide between actors who seem to say much the same thing in words. Sometimes it builds a bridge between groups that otherwise sound quite different.

This led us to propose the idea of visual discourse coalitions: networks of actors who share not only a similar way of talking about a controversy, but also a similar way of showing it.

The takeaway is that if we want to understand how camps form around contested technologies, we can’t only read what people write. We need to look at what they show, too.

Image credit: Public Herald/Flickr (cropped from original)