ipa conference

At the IPA Conference: Images Don’t Just Illustrate – Sometimes They Tell a Different Story

———

I contributed to the panel How Policy Conflicts Develop: Interpretation and Action in Policymaking at The 13th Interpretive Policy Analysis (IPA) Conference, held online.

My paper, co-authored with Karin Schroën and Tamara Metze, was called Dream or nightmare? Discursive and visual storylines of online sentiment coalitions on processed food.

The question driving the paper is this: processed food gets talked about online in very different ways – as a sensible answer to feeding a growing population sustainably, or as something to be wary of, with real risks to health and the environment. People expressing these views don’t just use words, they almost always pair their stance with an image. And yet, strangely, those images are rarely studied with the same care as the text.

In this paper, we looked at both the words and the images used by what we call ‘online sentiment coalitions’ – groups united by a shared stance, whether negative, positive, or neutral, towards processed food. What we saw is that while the words people used tended to match the overall tone of a webpage pretty closely, the images often didn’t just reinforce that tone, they introduced entirely new storylines that the text never mentioned.

In other words, if you only read the text, you’d miss part of the story.

It’s a small reminder that understanding the visual storylines – not just the written ones – matters more than we tend to give it credit for.